What is the best practice for invoicing a customer purchasing a trial printer and new consumables with one PO?

Hello All,

Anny comments or suggestions are greatly appreciated.


Background: 

We offer a trial program where potential customers can try a printer out and then decide to keep it and pay for it or send it back.  We process a sales order to ship the trial unit and this generates a trial invoice showing the list price of the printer.  The trial printer only comes with trial consumables that don't last very long so when most customers decide to keep and pay for their trial unit they often include new consumables on the same PO. 

Our Current Procedure:

When we receive a PO to keep the trial printer and purchase new consumables we have been  applying a credit memo to return that printer back into our system and cancel the trial invoice to zero.  We then generate a new sales order and line one is the printer they are keeping.  Below that we type in a comment on the sales order that says "Above Printer Kept From Trial, Only Ship Below Items" which signals our shipping department not to include a new printer on that shipment.  After that comment we enter in all the consumables the customer is purchasing.  The cost of the printer is often discounted slightly depending on how many consumables they buy at the same time they pay for the printer.

This results in having one "no-ship" item and multiple "ship" items on the same sales order.  We do this so we can have a single invoice in our system to match a single PO from the customer.  I am wondering if other companies doing something similar are sending two invoices to apply against the customers one PO?  I have a feeling that there must be a better way to handle this.  Does it make sense in this scenario to combine a standard sale and a trial purchase on the same invoice?  Is there some built in Trial functionality in MAS that we're missing?


What is the best practice in regards to processing a single PO for a customer purchasing a trial unit in their possession and ordering new items that need to be shipped?

  • 0

    You could have a negative line on your invoice for the return of the trial at whatever price the original invoice used and a regular line for the charge for the "real" price, but I am not sure it would be any better of a solution that what you are already doing.

  • 0 in reply to G Ulrich

    Following on the post from G Ulrich, if your credit and corresponding charge is done using miscellaneous items, there wouldn't be anything to ship on the second process.

    So, in other words, you have one Sales Order tied to on customer Purchase Order.  On the Sales Order is the trial printer (inventory item), a negative line for the amount of the trial and another line for the full purchase price of the printer.  You potentially will make two shippments and issue two invoices against the Sales Order; the first is for the ship and bill the trial unit and the second when they decide the purchase the unit.

    If the customer returns the trail unit, process an RMA for the printer with or without a credit to the customer (depending on the terms of the loan)  and cancel the remaining items on the order.  If the customer decides to keep the unit, process a second invoice for the miscellaeous items.

    Sample supplies can also be included.  If the customer wants additional supplies after deciding to keep the unit, add new item to the original sale order and the process a shipment for the balance of items.

    You might also consider adding a User Defined Field (UDF) to your Sales Order so you can track the status of trial units shipped.  Whent the unit is shipped, change the new field to a status of "Shipped".  If they return it, change the status to "Returned" while you process the cancellation of the order.  If they keep the unit, change the status to "Purchased".

    This way you can add the UDF to your Sales Order BIE view and then filter to just show orders for trial units that are still out on loan ("Shipped").  By using this flag and the ship date, you can have an easy way to manage your trial units and who has them.  You can also use the info for KPI tracking for things like Trial unit sale percentage, return percentage, Outstanding units, etc.